One Death at a Time
By: Abbi Waxman
Published Year: 2025
Publisher: Berkley
Pages: 400
I received a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. This in no way shape or form influenced my opinion of this novel.
Summary (Provided by Goodreads): When Julia Mann, a bad-tempered ex-actress and professional thorn in the side of authority, runs into Natasha Mason at an AA meeting, it’s anything but a meet-cute. Julia just found a dead body in her swimming pool, and the cops say she did it (she already went to jail for murder once, so now they think she’s making a habit of it). Mason is eager to clear Julia’s name and help keep her sober, but all Julia wants is for Mason to leave her alone.
As their investigation ranges from the Hollywood Hills to the world of burlesque to the country clubs of Palm Springs, this unconventional team realizes their shared love of sarcasm and poor life choices are proving to be a powerful combination. Will secrets from their past trip them up, or will their team of showgirls, cat burglars, and Hollywood agents help them stay one step ahead? Are dead piranhas, false noses, and a giant martini glass important clues or simply your typical day in Los Angeles? And will they manage to solve the crime before they kill each other, or worse, fall off the wagon? Trying to keep it simple and take it easy is one thing—trying to find a murderer before they kill again is a whole other program.
First Impressions
The cover looked like a cute cozy mystery. I also have read a lot of Waxman’s previous books, but they were more along the contemporary fictional lines. I was intrigued that she was testing out a mystery. I do love the cover and think I would’ve picked it up when I was wandering the library or a bookstore.
What I thought
Wow. There was way too much going on in this book.
Natasha Mason, who goes just by Mason, meets Julia Mann, a famous retired actress, at an AA meeting. Julia is court ordered to be there whereas Mason has been going for 3 years. When Mason becomes Julia’s interim sponsor, Julia sucks her into the case of finding out who murdered her old director turned nemesis Tony. Julia is currently the one suspected of the murder since it happened at her house.
I thought this was going to be a cute buddy comedy murder mystery but it just didn’t connect. I never really liked Mason or Julia. I wanted to so badly. Mason felt very flat to me, just repeating lines from AA books. I didn’t fully understand her sobriety journey or what it had to do with the story other than being a way for her to connect to Julia. And I was so annoyed when she would just randomly look at Julia and be like “you need to go to a meeting.” Why? What is Julia getting out of these meetings? Or even what is Mason getting out of these meetings?
Julia I did like a little bit more. She came of as brusque at first, but the more you learned about her the more it made sense. She collected a band of misfits around her which made her more likable, but the jump from Mason being her sponsor to being her right hand gal was a bit quick for me.
I also found that not only were there too many side characters for me to keep straight, but there were too many mysteries. Besides the main murder, there were at least 2 other murders in present day added to one that had happened in the past. Keeping everything straight was way too hard. At one point in the final quarter of the book, one of the characters even makes a Power Point to explain everything they know and how everything is connected. It felt like a way to remind the reader and help them get back into the story and mystery but I was even more confused. I ended up skimming the last 25% of the book because I just wanted to know who the murderer was.
The disappointing part what that the murderer was obvious. The motive was a bit convoluted and I felt like when Waxman was trying to tie everything back together she was making things up as she went. Honestly, I enjoyed the first half of the book. I thought maybe it was the type of series where they had to lay a lot of ground work and I would look forward to them solving more mysteries together in the future. Unfortunately, in the end I didn’t care about anyone.
This book is fine. If you like complex mysteries with a lot going on, you’ll enjoy it. Given that this is Waxman’s first mystery, I would be willing to give another book by her in the genre a chance. I don’t think I would read a second book with these characters though. They just weren’t my cup of tea.